I recently came across this article by Kurt Luther, founder of Civil War Photo Sleuth, an online tool for users to help identify individuals in images. In his piece in Military Images magazine, he deals with misidentified images of women soldiers. Among the photos he mentions is allegedly one of Jennie Hodgers in the collection of the Gilder Lehrman Institute. I was actually going to use it in my book. Sent the $165 check and everything. As you can see, the image is not viewable on their website. I assumed based on the description that it was the photo below. But when I received the image via Dropbox, it was not what I thought. And I had serious reservations about whether the soldier depicted was indeed Hodgers. It didn't look like her to me. And when I asked them to provide the provenance, they sent me a page from an auction house catalog they bought it from merely claiming the image to be Hodgers based on a resemblance to this photo: